Borrowers whose Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) loans are canceled in 2026 and beyond will owe federal income taxes on the discharged debt, potentially facing tax bills of up to $12,000 or more, according to a new analysis by Protect Borrowers.
The pandemic-era American Rescue Plan Act exempted discharged student loan debt from federal taxation through Dec. 31, 2025. Congress allowed that provision to expire, meaning IDR loans forgiven starting in 2026 will count as taxable income.
The nonprofit analysis found that the average discharged IDR loan is worth about $50,000, often exceeding the original loan amount because low income-based monthly payments do not cover ballooning interest.
A single borrower without children earning $40,000 annually in 2026 would owe over $10,000 in federal taxes on a discharged IDR loan. At $80,000 annual income, the tax bill climbs to nearly $20,000. After payroll and state taxes, such borrowers "could effectively see their take-home income cut nearly in half," according to the report.
For a family of four earning $40,000 annually, the total tax impact would be $10,558 in new taxes and lost tax credits combined, on top of their base expected tax bill.
Protect Borrowers called on lawmakers to permanently exempt discharged IDR loans from federal taxes during the next budget reconciliation process. A coalition of Democratic Senators made a similar request to the Trump administration last November. As of 2022, half of borrowers with canceled IDR debt had no bank account or nonretirement savings, citing Consumer Financial Protection Bureau survey data.