Five major school funding reports released over the past decade have reached conflicting conclusions about whether disadvantaged students receive less money than their wealthier peers.

EdBuild's 2019 analysis found that schools in predominantly nonwhite districts receive $23 billion less in annual funding than heavily white counterparts. A Brookings Institution report from July 2026 by economist Sarah Reber reached the opposite conclusion, finding that the poorest school districts receive the most money per pupil from all government sources.

The conflicting findings stem from different methodologies. Brookings counted all sources of school funding: local, state, and federal. EdBuild, EdTrust, and the Education Law Center counted only local and state dollars. The federal government provides more than $50 billion in school-related aid annually, including $18 billion in Title I funding for poor children. When federal funding is included in per-pupil spending calculations, poor school districts come out ahead in most states.

The five reports also differ on whether to adjust for regional cost differences. Teachers represent schools' biggest expense, and salaries vary geographically. EdBuild adjusted dollars for regional costs including housing prices. The Urban Institute showed how these adjustments change which districts appear better funded.

Poverty and race tell different funding stories. Many poor children attend predominantly white, rural schools, while Black and Hispanic students are more concentrated in cities where teacher labor costs are higher. EdTrust found that districts serving mostly Black, Hispanic and Native American students received $1,300 fewer state and local dollars per student than white students, but districts serving poor students received $200 more annually than nonpoor students.

Zahava Stadler, former policy director at EdBuild, said the different conclusions reflect different questions. "The fact is that when you ask different questions, you get different answers by design," she said at an August webinar.