When a school launches an esports program, the conversation often begins and ends with logistics: which game, what timetable, who supervises. But Jeffrey Cray, who co-founded Squid Academy and leads product development for its esports education programs, has identified a far more urgent gap. A school can tell you the game, the timetable and the supervision plan, but what matters most is what happens when voice chat turns hostile or a student needs to step away. That is where the well-being plan gets tested. Right now, most schools are failing that test.

The problem starts with incomplete planning. An age rating will not tell staff whether students can use voice chat, receive direct messages or end up in public lobbies. Schools need to try those features with the same account settings students will use. Otherwise, they are writing rules for a version of the game the students never see. Before students begin, schools must decide which channels are allowed, whether they will play with outsiders, and how they can report a problem privately to an adult. Students need to know what happens after they report it. If a player is mocked, excluded or pressured to stay online after a session, the response cannot depend on whichever teacher happens to hear about it first.

The response structure is critical. The adult receiving a report needs a clear next step: record what happened, decide whether a channel should be closed or restricted, and tell the student when they will hear back. Cray outlined this in a digital well-being workshop for secondary students during a school's Discovery Week. When he included slides on handling rude comments and situations like a friend left out of a group chat, he also added a slide on asking for help. One suggested opening was, 'This happened online – but it's affecting me in real life.' That is easier to use than a vague instruction to tell an adult.

Schools also need to monitor whether their programs are genuinely supporting well-being or simply providing screen time. Before a team plays, schools should agree on session length and what happens if someone needs to step away. After a match, staff should ask what felt difficult, not only what worked. Attendance alone will miss crucial signals. Schools need to notice who has stopped coming, who stays quiet and whether an incident changes the next session.

Parents deserve straightforward information, not sales pitches. A parent asking about screen time or online behaviour needs to know which game is being used, how long students play, who supervises, whether chat or public play is enabled, and whom to contact with a concern. When games change or competitions move to new platforms, staff must check settings again and update families. At the end of a rough session, the question should be simple: Will that student feel comfortable coming back next week? If the answer is uncertain, the program has not yet succeeded.