A trusted colleague recently declared that she has never seen more students more stressed out than she sees now. She's not the type prone to drama, so when she made this observation, it warranted serious attention. The concerning part isn't just that students are stressed—it's why they're stressed, and whether our institutions are adequately responding to the real sources of their anxiety.
On the surface, we might expect stress to ease as we move further from the pandemic and the 2008 recession. When the economy collapsed in 2008, enrollments hit historic peaks around 2009–10 as students sought shelter on campuses that felt like oases from the contracting economy. During the pandemic in 2020, anxiety spiked, but students maintained a belief that opportunities would await them after graduation. Today, something more fundamental has shifted. Students are facing two simultaneous pressures that previous crises never presented: immediate economic strain and existential uncertainty about whether their sacrifices will matter.
The immediate pressure is tangible. Gas prices spiked roughly $1.50 a gallon in the early spring and remain about $1.30 higher than a year prior. For students in areas with modest public transit systems who drive to campus and jobs, this sustained increase represents a genuine obstacle when they're already struggling to pay tuition and afford food. This isn't a temporary inconvenience—it's an ongoing drain on students living paycheck to paycheck.
But the deeper anxiety stems from AI's effect on the entry-level job market. Unless students pursue health care or skilled trades boosted by data centers, it's increasingly unclear which career fields offer a real future. This creates what Kyla Scanlon calls financial nihilism. Previous crises felt like intense storms that would pass and return to normal. AI threatens to hollow out better-paying jobs entirely, preventing the previous normal from ever returning. Young people trying to break into careers face an undefinable future—and they know it.
The combination is uniquely demoralizing. Education becomes simultaneously harder to access and less obviously a route to the middle class. Online classes help with transportation barriers, but they increase isolation with documented negative effects on retention, completion, and learning. Young adulthood is inherently stressful; making the world less legible to our students only compounds that stress.
We owe students more than sympathy. Institutions must help build skills likely to matter across multiple economic scenarios and offer whatever clarity we can about the world they'll inhabit longer than we will. Until we acknowledge that their stress isn't mere anxiety but a rational response to genuine uncertainty, we're asking them to sacrifice for futures we can't honestly promise.