The Supreme Court appeared receptive Tuesday to arguments that Catholic schools in Colorado should be able to exclude children of same-sex couples from a state universal preschool program while still receiving public funding.
Colorado's universal preschool benefit provides 15 hours of free preschool per week at public or private schools, worth about $6,000 per child. Schools participating must sign a nondiscrimination agreement that prohibits exclusion based on LGBTQ+ identity.
Catholic parishes and parents sued, claiming the nondiscrimination requirement violates their religious freedom under the First Amendment. They argue the provision prevents religious preschools from enrolling children of same-sex couples based on their faith teachings.
Justice Samuel Alito said there is "little evidence of a practical problem" and that LGBTQ+ couples could find "other preschools" if Catholic schools reject their children. Justice Brett Kavanaugh raised questions about where schools would draw lines on exclusions.
Nicholas Reaves, representing the petitioners, said Catholic families and schools "just want the same treatment" as others in the program. He said each diocese could decide where to draw the line on exclusions.
Helen Norton, representing Colorado's Department of Early Childhood, argued during oral arguments that schools advance equal opportunity by providing different treatment based on need, such as accommodations for visual impairments or addressing poverty-related barriers.
The court's ideologically conservative justices appeared inclined to allow religious schools receiving public funding to exclude families based on religious beliefs. The Supreme Court will release its decision during the 2026-27 term.
The case follows Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue (2020), in which the court ruled for a mother using a tax credit scholarship at a Christian school; Maine (2022), where the court found Maine violated the First Amendment by restricting religious schools from public tuition assistance; and Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission (2018), in which the court decided for a baker who refused service for a same-sex couple's wedding.