Policymakers increasingly focus on curriculum quality as a key lever for student learning, but two parallel movements—state evaluation of materials and federal emphasis on research evidence—have not combined to drive adoption of more effective curricula.
States and organizations like EdReports now rate curriculum materials for alignment to standards and usability. Mississippi's science of reading reforms have prompted other states to evaluate materials against reading science principles and encourage adoption of highly-rated options. The federal What Works Clearinghouse and projects like Evidence for ESSA at Johns Hopkins University set standards for evaluating whether curricula improve student outcomes using tiered evidence levels established in the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA).
Yet the research supporting curriculum effectiveness remains sparse and methodologically weak. A recent review of 36 publicly available studies of core K–5 English language arts curricula found pervasive problems. Five studies lacked control groups entirely. Sixteen failed to account for students being grouped in classrooms or schools. Most critically, not one study compared a curriculum to a named competitor, instead using generic "business-as-usual" comparisons that do not help districts choose among actual adoption options.
The Every Student Succeeds Act evidence tiers, enacted in December 2015, set standards intended to help leaders move beyond marketing claims. However, these tiers do not apply perfectly to core curriculum materials. Better guidelines would require longer time horizons of at least a full academic year, larger sample sizes across multiple sites, and greater value for quasi-experimental studies showing how curricula function at scale in schools.
Since ESSA's enactment a decade ago, states have largely failed to collect and share data on school district textbook adoptions. States could have partnered with external researchers to conduct evaluations using these data, but have not taken this approach. This gap in state-level action leaves researchers without essential data needed to study which curricula actually work.